Silk and wool are two of the most commonly used materials in Oriental rugs. Rugs made from either of these materials have different characteristics but both types look absolutely fabulous, making it really difficult to choose between the two.
So what exactly are the differences between silk rugs and wool rugs and which one would be a better choice for you?
How Do You Tell If A Rug Is Silk And Wool?
A larger number of weavers manufacture rugs using wool because they can easily source the material from sheep. They do not have to look for and purchase the material they require.
The quality of the finished rug depends largely on the age and breed of the sheep that the wool is sourced from as well as the climate and vegetation.
Oriental rugs made from wool have a matte appearance. They are soft to the touch and blend more easily into their surroundings.
Silk is more difficult to source and is also more expensive to procure, which can be major deterrents to tribal weavers who usually live in the remote mountains. These are mostly city rugs woven by skilled weavers who were not nomadic.
Silk rugs have a more lustrous appearance. They usually take longer to manufacture and have a higher knot count because of the thinner nature of the skin strands.
The Advantages Of Silk And Wool Rugs
Wool rugs have a thick, strong and dense pile, which makes them very durable. They are also resistant to stains and spills and do not get damaged easily even when placed in high traffic areas.
All of this makes them so much easier to maintain and keep clean with a periodic light sweeping and vacuuming.
Despite its deceptively fragile appearance, silk is a pretty strong fiber by itself.
However, the fiber gets damaged and breaks easily with excessive handling or when placed in high traffic areas and the rug tends to lose its sheen prematurely.
To prevent this from happening and to extend the life of your silk Oriental rug, it must be placed only in areas that do not get too much traffic and they must be handled very delicately when cleaning.
Using your silk rug as wall décor is the best way to prevent the rug from getting damaged.
How Much Does A Wool Silk Rug Cost?
Wool Oriental rugs cost much less than silk Oriental rugs of the same size. The higher price of silk rugs is a combination of both – the higher cost of the material and the additional labor involved in their creation.
Which Type Of Rug Is Better Suited To You?
If you would love to own an Oriental rug but you have a limited budget, you may want to start by checking out woolen rugs. While these may cost less than silk rugs, however, you should know that they are not necessarily cheap.
The cost of the rug will depend on its size, complexity of design, knots per square inch and place of manufacture.
Where you want to place your Oriental rug is another factor you should take into consideration. If you are looking for a rug to place at your entrance or in the kitchen, living room or dining room, you may be better off choosing a woolen rug, which is more durable and is better able to withstand the wear and tear of everyone walking over it.
If you are looking for a rug that you can use as a wall hanging or to uplift a quiet corner that does not get much traffic, it is definitely worth investing in a magnificent silk rug.
Are Wool and Silk Rugs Good?
Most Persian rugs are made from 100% wool. For a floor covering it is a natural choice, it is durable, easy to weave on a loom, can be dyed into many colors, and it is a readily available resource.
A small percentage of rugs woven from silk. Silk rugs are strong, but not as strong as wool. Getting silk, dyeing silk, and weaving silk is infinitely more laborious than wool.
The tensile properties of silk make it perfect for weaving intricate designs. Silk rugs are so exquisite and finely made, that most owners display them on the wall rather than the floor.
Due to the high cost of silk, silk rugs tend to be small, and or be made with a combination of silk and wool or silk and cotton.
The rug on the left is one of the most expensive Persian silk rugs sold. It sold in 2008 at an auction house for over 4 million dollars.
The rug on the right is a bargain in comparison. At 4×7 feet and pure silk, it is selling for under $7,000.
Buying Silk And Wool Persian Rugs
The most critical aspect to consider when buying a silk rug is ensuring that the silk you are buying comes from the silk worm cocoon. The word “silk” is sometimes used for a material that is cellulose based, like nylon, rather than protein based.
The difference in quality may not be apparent until years later when the fake silk deteriorates or needs to be cleaned.
Well cared for authentic silk rugs often appreciate in value, whereas a nylon rug will fall apart. You do not want to wait 20 years to find out that you were sold an inferior fiber rug.
Fine, antique wool can also imitate silk. Wool rugs are durable, but silk rugs cost considerably more. Therefore, you do not want to pay for silk unless you are actually buying silk.
Some dealers suggest a field test for silk by rubbing your hand on the silk. Supposedly, silk will generate heat, but nylon does not. Not even rug experts accurately perform this test. Others claim that if you pull a fiber from the fringe and burn it, silk will smell like burning hair and leave a distinct type of ash. The burn test is fairly accurate in distinguishing between nylon and silk.
Since silk and wool are both made from animal protein, the burn test is not 100% reliable for determining if a rug is silk or wool.
Do not trust the “rub test” or even the “burn test”. There is a chemical test that is very reliable but don’t try it at home. You can actually dissolve silk in a solution that does not affect nylon fibers.
A very practical alternative to silk rugs are fine wool rugs.
Wool Comes In Many Varieties And Qualities
By definition, wool comes from the hair of a mammal. Many different groups of people use different animals to harvest wool. Animal rugs could be made from goats, camels, sheep, even dogs.
However, Persian rugs are almost all made out of sheep wool. Even within the category of sheep wool, there are many gradations of quality determined by several factors.
Consideration 1: Was the sheep alive or dead? Wool that was harvested chemically after a sheep died is vastly inferior wool compared to wool sheared off a live sheep. The natural lanolin from live wool gets shiny and soft with age. Dead wool feels dry and brittle. Not only does dead wool not look as nice, it won’t last nearly as long.
A true Persian rug, from Iran, is almost guaranteed to be live wool.
Consideration 2: What type of sheep was it and where did the sheep live? Like any species that adapts to its environment, sheep can be vastly different depending breed and living conditions. Look at the difference in the wool with each sheep.
Consideration 3: How was the wool gathered and prepared? There are a variety of processes that can affect the quality of wool even when it all comes from one herd.
Combing the wool before turning it into thread, and using the wool from different parts of the body all affect the quality of the wool. The softest finest wool comes from the neck region and is thoroughly combed.
How To Buy A Wool Persian Rug
Each region of Iran has its special wool varieties. Peshawar often imports fine, silky wool from other countries. Bakhtyari weavers, in contrast, uses the best wool from its own herd. Both regions are known to use very high quality wool.
Before buying a wool rug, investigate the region that the rug comes from and the type of wool they use.
Since Persian rugs are named for the region they come from, the research won’t be too difficult. The vast rug encyclopedia found at our website is a great starting place. Here is all you need to know about Types of Oriental Rugs.